8+ Slack Time: How to Calculate it (Easy Guide)


8+ Slack Time: How to Calculate it (Easy Guide)

Figuring out the allowable delay in undertaking actions with out impacting the general undertaking timeline includes an important calculation. This calculation reveals the pliability inherent in scheduling particular duties. For example, if an exercise could be delayed by two days with out shifting the undertaking’s completion date, it possesses two days of schedule flexibility. This flexibility is a crucial part in undertaking administration.

Understanding schedule flexibility is useful for useful resource allocation and threat mitigation. Recognizing actions with appreciable leeway permits for the strategic deployment of assets to extra time-sensitive duties. Moreover, its measurement permits undertaking managers to proactively tackle potential delays and preserve undertaking schedules, thus making certain initiatives are accomplished on time and inside funds. These elements contribute to improved effectivity and diminished undertaking threat.

The next sections will elaborate on the strategies to find out the pliability in scheduling undertaking duties, presenting generally utilized methods and formulation.

1. Whole Float Calculation

Whole Float calculation represents a direct methodology to find out schedule flexibility. It quantifies the period of time an exercise could be delayed with out delaying the undertaking completion date. Thus, understanding and precisely calculating whole float is prime to figuring out leeway inside a undertaking schedule. The connection is direct: the results of the entire float calculation is the measure of schedule flexibility for a given exercise. If an exercise has a calculated whole float of zero, it lies on the crucial path and affords no leeway; any delay instantly impacts the undertaking finish date. Conversely, a constructive whole float signifies the quantity of permissible delay. For example, in establishing a constructing, the exercise of ‘putting in home windows’ might need a complete float of three days. This signifies that this exercise could be delayed by as much as three days with out pushing again the general completion of the constructing. This calculation permits undertaking managers to prioritize actions with minimal or unfavorable whole float, mitigating the chance of undertaking delays.

Completely different strategies exist to find out the entire float. The commonest includes subtracting the Early Begin (ES) from the Late Begin (LS) or the Early End (EF) from the Late End (LF) of an exercise. Correct willpower of those ‘early’ and ‘late’ occasions depends on a appropriately constructed undertaking community diagram and correct exercise period estimates. Errors in both of those upstream processes instantly impression the validity of the entire float calculations. A poorly outlined process dependency, for instance, will trigger the complete schedule to be unreliable. Furthermore, useful resource constraints not factored into the exercise period estimation can invalidate whole float estimations, significantly in initiatives with shared assets. This interdependency reinforces the necessity for a holistic and correct undertaking mannequin.

In abstract, the entire float calculation is an indispensable instrument for understanding schedule flexibility. Its accuracy is contingent upon the precision of underlying schedule information and the completeness of the undertaking community. Understanding whole float, particularly for actions on the crucial path, instantly permits undertaking managers to make knowledgeable selections concerning useful resource allocation, threat administration, and proactive schedule changes, to maximise the probabilities of undertaking success. Inaccurate calculations present a false sense of safety and doubtlessly detrimental penalties on the schedule baseline.

2. Free Float Identification

Free Float identification affords a refined perspective on schedule flexibility, complementing the broader understanding gained from strategies targeted on its calculation. It pinpoints the period a process could be delayed with out affecting the Early Begin (ES) of any instantly following process. This distinction is crucial for environment friendly useful resource allocation and threat administration.

  • Definition and Significance

    Free Float is the period of time an exercise could be delayed with out impacting subsequent actions’ begin occasions. Not like Whole Float, which considers undertaking completion date, Free Float is worried with instant successors. This distinction makes it invaluable for task-level scheduling and useful resource optimization. For instance, if a software program growth process has a Free Float of two days, it may be delayed by two days with out affecting the builders engaged on the following module.

  • Calculation Methodology

    Free Float calculation includes subtracting the Early End (EF) of an exercise from the earliest of the Early Begins (ES) of its instant successors. The system is: Free Float = Min(ES of successors) – EF of exercise. In sensible software, precisely mapping dependencies between actions is essential. If dependencies are incorrectly outlined, the ensuing Free Float values will probably be deceptive, resulting in inefficient scheduling selections.

  • Useful resource Allocation and Prioritization

    Identification of Free Float assists within the allocation of assets. Actions with low or zero Free Float require prioritized useful resource allocation to stop delays cascading by means of the undertaking. Conversely, actions with vital Free Float enable undertaking managers the pliability to reassign assets to extra crucial duties, enhancing general undertaking effectivity. Development initiatives typically make the most of this precept, shifting expert labor to areas the place delays instantly threaten the undertaking timeline.

  • Danger Mitigation and Contingency Planning

    Free Float supplies a buffer towards unexpected delays. Actions with larger Free Float supply larger capability to soak up sudden points, thereby lowering the chance of impacting subsequent duties. This info is invaluable for contingency planning. By understanding which actions possess Free Float, undertaking managers can higher allocate contingency reserves and develop mitigation methods to attenuate the ripple impact of delays.

In essence, Free Float identification supplies a granular view of schedule flexibility. By understanding the interaction between actions and their instant successors, undertaking groups could make data-driven selections concerning useful resource allocation, process prioritization, and threat mitigation, optimizing the undertaking schedule and enhancing the chance of on-time undertaking completion. The insights gained from figuring out free float instantly help the efficient software of rules utilized in strategies for calculating slack.

3. Mission Community Diagram

The undertaking community diagram serves as a basic part within the willpower of schedule flexibility, instantly impacting the outcomes of varied strategies for its calculation. A undertaking community diagram, visually representing undertaking actions and their dependencies, establishes the sequence of duties and the relationships that dictate undertaking workflow. Errors or omissions on this diagram instantly translate into inaccuracies when figuring out schedule flexibility, because the calculated Early Begin, Late Begin, and subsequently, the float values, rely totally on the depicted community.

The diagram’s position is particularly crucial in Crucial Path Technique (CPM) evaluation. The crucial path, decided by means of ahead and backward passes on the community, dictates the minimal undertaking period. Strategies to calculate schedule flexibility depend on figuring out the crucial path appropriately. An inaccurate undertaking community diagram can result in a misidentified crucial path, leading to a false sense of schedule flexibility for actions not actually crucial, and conversely, an underestimation of the criticality of these on the precise path. For example, in software program growth, if a dependency between the “database design” and “API growth” duties is omitted from the community, the schedule leeway attributed to those duties will probably be incorrectly assessed, doubtlessly resulting in delays when API growth is unexpectedly hindered by database design points. The accuracy of the diagram is subsequently a direct precursor to legitimate flexibility calculations.

In conclusion, the undertaking community diagram constitutes the cornerstone upon which correct flexibility calculations are constructed. Its readability, accuracy, and comprehensiveness are important for dependable undertaking scheduling. Neglecting the meticulous development and upkeep of this diagram undermines the integrity of all subsequent strategies, thereby jeopardizing the profitable execution of the undertaking. Steady validation and refinement of the undertaking community diagram are crucial for efficient schedule management and well timed undertaking completion.

4. Crucial Path Evaluation

Crucial Path Evaluation (CPA) supplies the foundational framework for understanding and quantifying schedule flexibility. The method identifies the sequence of actions that dictate the minimal undertaking completion time. These actions, forming the crucial path, inherently possess zero schedule flexibility; any delay in these duties instantly impacts the undertaking deadline. As such, CPA is indispensable for correctly figuring out the extent of allowable delays elsewhere throughout the schedule.

  • Identification of the Crucial Path

    The preliminary step in CPA includes mapping all undertaking actions and their dependencies, normally represented in a community diagram. The longest path by means of this community, when it comes to cumulative exercise durations, is the crucial path. For instance, in establishing a bridge, the crucial path could embrace actions resembling basis laying, pier development, and deck set up. Incorrectly figuring out the crucial path invalidates subsequent makes an attempt to determine schedule flexibility, as assets could also be misallocated, and non-critical actions could obtain undue consideration.

  • Calculation of Early and Late Begin/End Occasions

    CPA employs ahead and backward passes by means of the community diagram to find out the earliest and newest potential begin and end occasions for every exercise. These occasions are essential for figuring out the schedule flexibility of non-critical actions. Actions on the crucial path could have equal early and late begin/end occasions, indicating zero schedule flexibility. Take into account a software program growth undertaking: If a coding process has an Early Begin (ES) of day 10 and a Late Begin (LS) of day 10, it signifies that any delay in that coding process will delay the complete undertaking. Precisely figuring out these values is a precondition for correct calculations associated to schedule flexibility.

  • Dedication of Whole Float (Schedule Flexibility)

    As soon as early and late begin/end occasions are established, Whole Float (sometimes called schedule flexibility or allowable delay) could be calculated for every exercise. Whole Float represents the utmost period of time an exercise could be delayed with out delaying the undertaking completion date. Actions on the crucial path have a Whole Float of zero. For example, if a advertising marketing campaign exercise has a Whole Float of 5 days, it may be delayed by as much as 5 days with out affecting the general marketing campaign launch date. Understanding the distinction within the schedule flexibility between crucial and non-critical path actions permits undertaking managers to successfully allocate assets and mitigate dangers.

  • Influence of Adjustments and Contingency Planning

    CPA facilitates the evaluation of the impression of any modifications to the undertaking plan. If an exercise on the crucial path is delayed, it instantly impacts the undertaking completion date. Moreover, CPA aids in contingency planning by figuring out which actions have accessible Whole Float and might, subsequently, take up sudden delays with out affecting the general schedule. For instance, a delay within the supply of supplies may be absorbed by an exercise with adequate Whole Float. This method ensures that the undertaking group can react proactively to unexpected challenges and preserve the undertaking schedule.

In abstract, Crucial Path Evaluation supplies the scaffolding for figuring out the schedule flexibility inside a undertaking. By the identification of the crucial path, the calculation of early and late begin/end occasions, and the following willpower of Whole Float, CPA permits undertaking managers to strategically handle assets, assess dangers, and implement contingency plans to extend the chance of on-time undertaking completion. Its accuracy instantly underpins the validity of any conclusions associated to schedule flexibility.

5. Early Begin Occasions

The Early Begin Time (ES) of an exercise is a foundational factor in figuring out schedule flexibility. It represents the earliest potential cut-off date that an exercise can start, based mostly on previous duties and undertaking constraints. The ES worth, instantly integrated into formulation for schedule flexibility, exerts an important affect on the end result. An inaccurate ES calculation propagates errors, doubtlessly resulting in a misjudgment of the undertaking’s true schedule leeway.

The connection is a cause-and-effect relationship. Incorrectly estimated durations of predecessor duties, or a flawed community diagram depicting incorrect process dependencies, results in an inaccurate ES. Consequently, when using calculations, the flawed ES yields an incorrect float worth. For instance, if the ES for putting in electrical wiring in a constructing is calculated too early as a result of the previous process of wall development is underestimated, the resultant float will probably be artificially inflated. Mission managers, counting on this inflated flexibility, could delay electrical wiring solely to find that the general undertaking timeline is now jeopardized. This state of affairs underscores the crucial significance of correct and reasonable estimation when establishing ES values. The downstream impact on figuring out schedule flexibility is important.

In conclusion, the ES is a crucial enter to determine undertaking’s capability to adapt to sudden occurrences, or sudden slack, or sudden change. The accuracy and realism within the calculation of the ES values are important for efficient undertaking administration and threat mitigation. A seemingly small error in figuring out an ES can have cascading results, finally resulting in incorrect calculations of schedule flexibility and doubtlessly compromising the success of the undertaking.

6. Late Begin Occasions

Late Begin Time (LS) represents the most recent potential second an exercise can start with out jeopardizing the undertaking’s predefined completion date. Its willpower is integral to assessing schedule flexibility, functioning as a cornerstone throughout the calculations used to quantify that flexibility. The LS, together with the Early Begin (ES), defines the parameters inside which an exercise could be scheduled, instantly impacting the calculated float values.

  • Definition and Calculation

    LS is derived by means of a backward cross evaluation of the undertaking community diagram. It considers the deadlines of subsequent duties and the general undertaking finish date. The system typically includes subtracting the exercise period from the Late End (LF) time. Inaccurate LF values, or flawed undertaking community dependencies, compromise the accuracy of the LS. For example, if the scheduled supply of specialised tools is delayed, the LS of dependent development actions is correspondingly affected.

  • Relationship to Whole Float

    LS is instrumental in calculating Whole Float, which instantly signifies the schedule flexibility accessible for an exercise. Whole Float is the distinction between LS and ES (or LF and Early End). The next Whole Float suggests larger schedule leeway, whereas a Whole Float of zero signifies that the exercise lies on the crucial path and possesses no flexibility. If the LS for a crucial process is miscalculated, the consequence is usually a false sense of schedule flexibility, resulting in useful resource misallocation and potential undertaking delays.

  • Useful resource Administration Implications

    The LS informs useful resource allocation selections. Actions with a later LS can doubtlessly be scheduled later, permitting assets to be redirected to duties with much less schedule flexibility. Conversely, actions with an early LS should be prioritized. Take into account a state of affairs in a advertising marketing campaign: If the LS for creating promotional supplies is comparatively late, designers can allocate their time to different duties with imminent deadlines. A transparent understanding of the LS subsequently assists in environment friendly useful resource leveling.

  • Danger Evaluation and Mitigation

    LS supplies insights for threat evaluation and mitigation methods. Actions with a good LS (i.e., LS near the ES) are extra susceptible to disruptions and require nearer monitoring. Contingency plans ought to be in place for these actions to stop delays from cascading by means of the undertaking. For instance, if the LS for regulatory approval is constrained, proactive measures, resembling early submission and fixed communication with regulatory our bodies, turn out to be essential to mitigate the chance of schedule slippage.

The LS, subsequently, is just not merely a scheduling parameter however a pivotal enter that has repercussions throughout varied features of undertaking administration. Its accuracy instantly impacts the willpower of schedule flexibility, influencing useful resource allocation, threat administration, and general undertaking success. Correct methodologies and cautious consideration are paramount to making sure its validity, maximizing undertaking effectivity and lowering the potential for pricey delays.

7. Exercise Period Estimation

Exercise Period Estimation constitutes a crucial upstream course of that instantly influences the accuracy and reliability of schedule flexibility calculations. The method entails forecasting the time required to finish every exercise inside a undertaking. This forecast acts as a foundational enter for figuring out the Early Begin, Late Begin, and subsequent float, profoundly affecting general undertaking scheduling and threat evaluation.

  • Influence on Early and Late Begin Occasions

    Misguided period estimates propagate by means of the schedule, distorting Early and Late Begin occasions. An underestimated exercise period ends in artificially early ES and LS values for subsequent duties, whereas overestimated durations produce artificially late begin occasions. These inaccuracies compromise the validity of flexibility metrics. For instance, if the time wanted to accumulate needed permits for a development undertaking is underestimated, the ES and LS of dependent development actions will probably be miscalculated, resulting in an inaccurate evaluation of schedule leeway.

  • Direct Affect on Whole Float Calculation

    Whole Float, calculated utilizing ES and LS, quantifies the accessible schedule flexibility for every exercise. When exercise period estimates are imprecise, the ensuing Whole Float calculations turn out to be unreliable. An exercise with a falsely excessive Whole Float could lull undertaking managers right into a false sense of safety, whereas an exercise with a falsely low Whole Float could set off pointless useful resource allocation. For example, if the time to debug a software program module is considerably underestimated, the calculated Whole Float will probably be decrease than actuality. This may occasionally trigger assets to be diverted unnecessarily to this module, hindering progress on different duties.

  • Penalties for Crucial Path Evaluation

    Inaccurate exercise period estimation can result in a misidentification of the crucial path. The crucial path, outlined because the longest path by means of the undertaking community, dictates the minimal undertaking completion time. If the period of an exercise on the true crucial path is underestimated, the trail could also be incorrectly recognized, resulting in a misallocation of assets and finally, undertaking delays. Take into account a undertaking to develop a brand new pharmaceutical drug: Underestimating the time to acquire regulatory approval may masks its crucial path standing, resulting in insufficient contingency planning and potential delays within the drug’s launch.

  • Results on Useful resource Leveling and Allocation

    Useful resource leveling and allocation selections depend on correct exercise period estimates. If actions are estimated too quick, assets could also be over-allocated, resulting in burnout and diminished productiveness. Conversely, if actions are estimated too lengthy, assets could also be under-utilized, resulting in inefficiencies. If the period of a testing part is overestimated, undertaking managers could prematurely reallocate testers to different duties, solely to search out that extra testing is required, disrupting the rigorously balanced useful resource schedule.

In conclusion, Exercise Period Estimation stands as a cornerstone of efficient undertaking scheduling and instantly impacts the accuracy of schedule flexibility measures. It’s important to make use of sturdy estimation methods, incorporating historic information, knowledgeable judgment, and reasonable threat assessments, to make sure that exercise period estimates are as correct as potential. This accuracy, in flip, helps knowledgeable decision-making concerning useful resource allocation, threat administration, and undertaking scheduling, optimizing the probabilities of profitable undertaking completion.

8. Useful resource Availability Influence

The consideration of Useful resource Availability Influence is crucial for the correct willpower of schedule flexibility. Its evaluation includes recognizing the constraint useful resource limitations impose on undertaking actions, and the way these limitations instantly have an effect on calculations pertaining to schedule leeway. It’s a issue that should be built-in into undertaking planning to replicate reasonable situations.

  • Useful resource Constraints and Activity Period

    Useful resource constraints typically lengthen process durations past their very best timelines. Restricted entry to specialised tools, inadequate staffing, or competing undertaking calls for can lengthen the completion of actions. This elongation instantly impacts the Early and Late Begin occasions, and consequently, the calculated flexibility or float. For example, if a development crew is just accessible for 3 days every week resulting from different undertaking commitments, the period of duties reliant on that crew will probably be prolonged, thereby lowering the accessible leeway.

  • Influence on Crucial Path Identification

    Useful resource constraints can shift the crucial path. Actions that originally seem to have schedule flexibility could turn out to be crucial if their useful resource wants battle with different duties. This requires a resource-leveled crucial path evaluation, which adjusts process scheduling based mostly on useful resource availability. For instance, if a software program growth undertaking has two seemingly unbiased modules, however each require the identical senior developer, the developer’s restricted availability may make one of many modules crucial, eliminating any beforehand perceived schedule flexibility.

  • Affect on Whole Float and Free Float

    Useful resource constraints instantly scale back each Whole Float and Free Float. Whole Float displays the utmost allowable delay with out impacting the undertaking finish date, whereas Free Float signifies the delay permissible with out affecting subsequent actions. Useful resource limitations diminish these float values. Suppose that tools upkeep, initially deliberate with every week of flexibility, can solely be carried out throughout a selected two-day window resulting from technician availability. In such a case, the entire float is diminished to 2 days as dictated by Useful resource Availability Influence.

  • Contingency Planning Issues

    Useful resource availability should inform contingency planning. Mission plans ought to account for potential useful resource bottlenecks and develop methods to mitigate their impression. This might contain cross-training personnel, securing extra assets, or adjusting process priorities. Failure to contemplate useful resource constraints in contingency planning can render schedule flexibility calculations meaningless. An instance of this may be failing to account for backup servers and IT personnel, leaving a undertaking fully susceptible within the occasion of a server outage. This oversight would void all calculations based mostly on the belief of steady computing assets.

In summation, the consideration of Useful resource Availability Influence is prime for an correct evaluation of schedule flexibility. Useful resource limitations typically invalidate preliminary calculations and necessitate a resource-leveled evaluation to attain a sensible understanding of undertaking timelines and potential delays. This understanding promotes knowledgeable decision-making, enabling undertaking managers to successfully allocate assets, handle dangers, and implement contingency plans that replicate real-world constraints.

Steadily Requested Questions About Calculating Slack

This part addresses widespread inquiries regarding the strategies, interpretation, and software of calculating schedule flexibility inside undertaking administration. These solutions goal to supply readability and sensible steerage for undertaking professionals.

Query 1: What’s the basic distinction between Whole Float and Free Float?

Whole Float signifies the permissible delay for an exercise with out extending the undertaking’s general completion date. Free Float, conversely, signifies the allowable delay with out affecting the Early Begin of any instantly subsequent exercise. Whole Float considers the undertaking finish date, whereas Free Float focuses on instant successors.

Query 2: How does an inaccurate undertaking community diagram have an effect on the calculation of float?

An inaccurate undertaking community diagram, which inadequately depicts process dependencies, compromises the reliability of float calculations. Omissions or errors within the diagram result in miscalculated Early and Late Begin occasions, thereby producing inaccurate float values. This misrepresentation undermines knowledgeable decision-making.

Query 3: Why is Exercise Period Estimation essential for correct float calculation?

Exercise Period Estimation supplies the inspiration for figuring out Early and Late Begin occasions. Inaccurate exercise period estimates instantly have an effect on the calculated float values. Underestimated durations can present a false sense of safety, whereas overestimated durations can result in useful resource inefficiencies.

Query 4: How do useful resource constraints impression schedule flexibility?

Useful resource limitations can severely limit schedule flexibility. Actions initially showing to have leeway can turn out to be crucial if assets are scarce or unavailable. This necessitates a resource-leveled crucial path evaluation to precisely assess schedule flexibility below reasonable constraints.

Query 5: What’s the significance of the crucial path in figuring out schedule flexibility?

The crucial path, comprising actions with zero float, dictates the minimal undertaking period. Accurately figuring out the crucial path is crucial for allocating assets successfully and managing threat. Any delay in a crucial path exercise instantly extends the undertaking completion date.

Query 6: How can undertaking managers make the most of schedule flexibility info to enhance undertaking outcomes?

Understanding the float permits undertaking managers to strategically allocate assets, prioritize duties, and implement contingency plans. Actions with restricted or unfavorable float require shut monitoring and proactive administration, whereas actions with ample float supply flexibility in useful resource deployment and threat mitigation.

In abstract, calculating schedule flexibility, or slack, supplies invaluable insights for undertaking administration. Its correct software depends on correct information, a transparent understanding of undertaking dependencies, and cautious consideration of useful resource constraints.

The subsequent part will present finest practices for making use of the mentioned ideas.

Ideas for Calculating Schedule Flexibility

The next affords sensible recommendation to boost the precision and utility of schedule flexibility calculations inside undertaking administration. Adhering to those tips helps knowledgeable decision-making and minimizes undertaking dangers.

Tip 1: Prioritize Correct Exercise Period Estimates: Imprecise exercise period estimates undermine the complete schedule evaluation. Make use of historic information, knowledgeable consultations, and reasonable threat assessments to refine the precision of those estimations. Usually replace estimates as new info turns into accessible throughout undertaking execution.

Tip 2: Meticulously Assemble the Mission Community Diagram: The undertaking community diagram varieties the spine of schedule evaluation. Be certain that all actions and their dependencies are precisely represented. Validate the diagram with undertaking stakeholders to establish and rectify potential errors or omissions earlier than commencing schedule calculations.

Tip 3: Account for Useful resource Constraints: Combine useful resource availability into schedule calculations. Useful resource limitations can considerably have an effect on exercise durations and shift the crucial path. Conduct useful resource leveling to establish and tackle potential bottlenecks earlier than they impression undertaking timelines.

Tip 4: Usually Replace and Recalculate Float Values: The undertaking atmosphere is dynamic. Surprising delays, scope modifications, and useful resource changes necessitate frequent updates to the schedule and recalculations of float values. Implement a course of for steady monitoring and schedule upkeep.

Tip 5: Distinguish Between Whole Float and Free Float: Make use of each Whole Float and Free Float to realize a complete understanding of schedule flexibility. Whole Float informs general project-level selections, whereas Free Float guides task-level scheduling and useful resource allocation.

Tip 6: Use Software program Instruments for Schedule Evaluation: Mission administration software program instruments automate schedule calculations, together with the willpower of float values. Leverage these instruments to boost effectivity, scale back errors, and facilitate state of affairs planning.

Tip 7: Talk Schedule Flexibility Info: Share schedule flexibility info with undertaking stakeholders. Clear communication promotes collaboration, facilitates proactive problem-solving, and fosters a shared understanding of undertaking dangers and alternatives.

Constantly making use of the following tips enhances the validity and utility of schedule flexibility calculations, enabling undertaking managers to make data-driven selections, mitigate dangers, and optimize undertaking outcomes.

The concluding part of this dialogue reinforces the significance and supplies a abstract of key ideas.

Conclusion

The previous dialogue has underscored the important nature of understanding find out how to calculate slack in undertaking administration. Correct evaluation of schedule flexibility, from figuring out the crucial path to evaluating useful resource constraints, allows knowledgeable decision-making, proactive threat administration, and environment friendly useful resource allocation. The strategies outlined, when rigorously utilized, present a sturdy framework for optimizing undertaking schedules and mitigating the potential for delays.

The rules mentioned characterize a dedication to data-driven undertaking administration. Steady validation of schedule parameters and proactive changes based mostly on sound calculation are paramount to attaining undertaking success. The way forward for efficient undertaking administration resides within the software of those methods to not solely predict however to actively form undertaking outcomes.